You know… I’ve decided that I really don’t like working for the independent school system.
On first thought, I can’t understand what I couldn’t like about it, can’t believe I’d be anything but happy here. The children are exceptional. I can’t even remember a time when 100% of the children who accidentally bumped into me in a crowded hallway at an overburdened public school… stopped in his or her tracks, met my eyes, and offered a genuine apology. Can I remember a time when the children, confident and articulate, stopped to chat at my desk for no other reason than they were passing by and realized they hadn’t said hello in a while? Have I ever been in an environment outside of my own household where a third of the words exchanged are simple pleasantries such as “please” and “thank you”?
And yet, I’ve decided that I don’t like it here. The children are beautiful and intelligent creatures, well-behaved but still vivacious, creative and innovative. They are, in short, what I think all children in an ideal world would be if they were all offered environments such as this.
But they’re not. The children here are selected from a huge pool of applicants. Beautiful and intelligent children are turned away at the door… and I wonder what becomes of them. I really do. Just like I wonder how many children in the public school system have fallen through the cracks while an overburdened teacher with thirty young charges struggles just to keep a few of them afloat… in the time it takes one teacher at an independent school to recognize one of her ten students is struggling and places a call to the parents. In the time it takes that teacher to place the call and to avert a problem before it can even be called one… how many equally deserving children have been utterly failed by a system that refuses to support them simply because their parents can’t afford lunches, let alone $20,000/year tuition?
These children pay more for a couple years of preschool than I did for a degree from Berkeley. I certainly don’t begrudge them an excellent education; no one could begrudge that! Education in all forms is beautiful, precious commodity, one of the few things one can have in this world that will never depreciate over time, something that will always offer solutions and something that can be passed on to the next generation regardless of fame, fortune, or luck of the draw.
But the disparity between the quality of education a rich child gets and the quality of education a poor child gets is appalling. And that’s all it comes down to, really, isn’t it? A child from a rich family can go to a good school and learn in an intimate, engaging environment with ten other children where his individual needs are addressed foremost, go to the best upper schools, go to the best universities, and get the highest paying jobs. And a child from a poor family -a child of equal intellectual mettle as the first - does the best he can in an environment where his teacher, a professional who is as personally invested in his future as the independent school teacher but without the same means to support him, has thirty other students to care for, thirty other sets of needs to consider.
It breaks my heart for the teachers too. I imagine my mother, a dedicated public school teacher, seeing the opulence, the luxury, that is the school where I work. I imagine she would go home and still bury herself under a mound of papers to be graded and projects to be reviewed… but instead of expressions of sadness, hope, determination, and resignation battling for dominance on her face, I would see only the hope and determination.
But… it occurs to me that my mother would never work at an independent school for precisely those reasons. I don’t think she could ever live with herself if she took the “easy” route, choosing to help children who can already afford the best versus the equally bright children who have nothing but their own burgeoning dreams.
And to the same ends, I think that’s why I don’t like it here. These are beautiful, wonderful children… and I hate that all our children aren’t given the opportunities to grow like this. I hate that rich kids can afford what equally deserving children cannot, further widening a chasm between them that neither deserve. I hate it. It hate it for the children. I hate it for the teachers. And I hate the world it creates.